February 23, 2006


   Home Page

 News & Features


 Columns & Opinions

   Publisher's Note





 Pop Culture



   Video Games
   CD Reviews




   Grazing Guide



   Music Roundup

   Live Music/DJs

   MP3 & Podcasts





 Find A Hippo




   View Classified Ads

   Place a Classified Ad




 Contact Us

   Hippo Staff

   How to Reach The Hippo

 Past Issues

   Browse by Cover

Techie: Go directly to iJail
All in all, it’s just another brick in the wall
By John “jaQ” Andrews  jandrews@hippopress.com

Ever transfer songs from a CD you bought to your iPod? Prepare to have your house invaded by federal agents.

OK, that’s a little extreme. But if the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) has its way, that little activity you thought was perfectly legal could put you on America’s Most Wanted.

The RIAA, which represents the major music labels, recently argued that at present, permission to copy music to an MP3 player or other format is “often or even ‘routinely’ granted,” and that such permission doesn’t necessarily mean that a copyright holder wouldn’t be perfectly within its rights to withhold that permission.

Quick, check the liner notes of all your CDs. Anyone who e-mails me a scan of a major label album specifically giving permission to rip the music to an MP3 player wins a special prize.

I don’t expect to have to give anyone a prize (which, let’s face it, would probably consist of a “Congratulations!” e-card or something). The fact is, that permission to copy isn’t ever explicitly granted. It’s implicit in something called the Doctrine of Fair Use. Courts have found for decades that techniques for time-shifting (taping Olympic ice dancing on your VCR to watch the next morning) and space-shifting (putting the White Album on cassette so you can listen to it in your car) are perfectly legitimate, legal activities. It’s also been established that making a backup copy of your media is legal.

A few years ago, though, Congress passed something called the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA). In short, this legislation said, “Computers make it really easy to make perfect digital copies of stuff. Oh crap.” And the industry has been proposing new restrictions on Fair Use ever since.

“The [Copyright] Register was right in 2003 to be ‘skeptical’ of the merits of any fair use analysis that asserts that space-shifting or format-shifting is a noninfringing use,” says a filing submitted by the RIAA in DMCA rule-making proceedings recently. “This is particularly the case in today’s market, where inexpensive legitimate digital copies of most types of works are readily available, and increasingly can be obtained through online download services.”

Simply put, the RIAA is saying that since you can buy your album again from iTunes, you shouldn’t be allowed to rip it to your iPod. If this sounds a little unfair, well, life isn’t fair, cupcake, and laws in a liberal democracy have absolutely no role in making it such.

Speaking of the White Album, my copy, which I bought in a consignment store a few years back, was stolen. Can I get a backup hookup?

 Comments? Thoughts? Discuss these articles and more at hippoflea.com

02/16/2006 Will you stamp your e-mail?
02/09/2006 War of the machines
02/02/2006 Faster than a speeding packet
01/26/2006 Free software made simple
01/19/2006 The Worst of CES
01/12/2006 Radio you
01/05/2006 Making Movies
A browser is to a car as ...

Behold, the $100 laptop
Beyond VCRs, Part 2
Beyond VCRs
Back-to-school basics
Big Brother is printing
Books without the paper
Essential Gadgets
Get it while it’s hot, used
High-tech garage sale
In touch with the future
Last-minute dork presents
Make your mark
Memory in your pocket
Microsoft must be scratching its head
No strings attached
Plastic junk for Halloween
Power up

Satellite radio showdown

The sound of your voice
There ain’t no such thing as free music
Want to watch cable in every nook and cranny?